Best of the Best: Who Are the NFL’s Real 2021 All-Pro Players?
NFL

Best of the Best: Who Are the NFL’s Real 2021 All-Pro Players?

The NFL Pro Bowl looks like an extremely fun time for all concerned, particularly this year in Las Vegas, but it is hardly representative of who the very best players were during the 2021 season.

With Super Bowl participants obviously not playing and a host of players dropping out to allow their bodies to heal from the rigors of playing a 17-week season plus postseason campaigns, this glorified scrimmage does not really live up to the title of ‘All-Star Game.’

The Associated Press All-Pro team is seen as a better measure of who was among the elite in a given season, but even that is dependent on the subjective opinion of a panel 50 journalists.

There are a host of measures by which we can gauge who performed at the highest level, and we have used those to create The Analyst’s All-Pro team for 2021.

OFFENSE

Quarterback

First Team: Joe Burrow, Cincinnati Bengals

Second Team: Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers

An appearance in the Super Bowl is no more than the Houdini-esque Burrow deserves. He led all quarterbacks (minimum 200 attempts) with a well-thrown ball on 86.5% of attempts and was fourth in QB EVE – yards gained over expected in expected passing situations. Rodgers was second in the latter category but his well-thrown percentage of 77.8 comfortably trailed that of Burrow.

2021 well-thrown percentage

Running Back

First Team: Jonathan Taylor, Indianapolis Colts

Second Team: Nick Chubb, Cleveland Browns

The heartbeat of the Colts’ offense, no player could match Taylor’s efficiency relative to his volume. He carried the ball 332 times compared to Chubb’s 228 and still averaged under a yard less per carry than the Browns star (5.45 yards to 5.52) while essentially matching him in yards before contact per attempt (3.41 to 3.44) and equaling Chubb in yards after contact per rush (both 2.17). The only area where Chubb had a clear advantage was on yards per carry with a run disruption, where he averaged 4.33 to Taylor’s 3.51.

Wide Receiver

First Team: Cooper Kupp, Los Angeles Rams; Justin Jefferson, Minnesota Vikings; Mike Evans, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Second Team: Stefon Diggs, Buffalo Bills; Davante Adams, Green Bay Packers; Ja’Marr Chase, Cincinnati Bengals

No wideout with 100 targets had more burn yards per route than the Rams’ conference championship game hero Kupp, who averaged 4.0. Jefferson (3.7) was close, while Evans’ combined win percentage against both man and zone coverage of 50.46 was tops for all receivers with at least 100 matchups. Evans also led all receivers with 100 targets with a big-play rate of 43.1%, a list on which Chase (37.5) was third behind Jefferson (38).

Tight End

First Team: Travis Kelce, Kansas City Chiefs

Second Team: George Kittle, San Francisco 49ers

Kelce enjoyed another season in which he reaffirmed his status as the top receiving tight end in the game, with a combined win percentage against man and zone second of 40.68 second only to Darren Waller (46.32), who played in only 11 games. Kittle still has a case for the title of the most complete player at his position. He was top five in burn yards per route at his position with 3.1 and ranked sixth among tight ends with at least 50 one on one run-blocking matchups with a double-team adjusted win rate of 81.69%. No tight end had more than his 129 one on ones.

Blocking Tight End

First Team: Will Dissly, Seattle Seahawks

Second Team: Marcedes Lewis, Green Bay Packers

Dissly (82.54%) was one of the few tight ends to produce superior play when it came to run blocking. Lewis (79.67) also thrived in that area while also finishing 11th among tight ends with at least 10 targets in burn yards per route with 2.4.

Left Tackle

First Team: Trent Williams, San Francisco 49ers

Second Team: Rashawn Slater, Los Angeles Chargers

Williams deservedly received some NFL Offensive Player of the Year talk through finishing second among tackles with a minimum of 125 one-on-one matchups in stunt adjusted pass protection win rate (91.81%) and first in double-team adjusted run block win rate (84.07%). No player had more pass protection one on ones than Slater’s 358 and he still managed to win 90.51% of them.

Left Guard

First Team: Joel Bitonio, Cleveland Browns

Second Team: Ali Marpet, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

No guard had more one on one run-blocking matchups than Bitonio, yet he still led all guards with a minimum of 100 with an adjusted win rate of 84.18%. He was also third in adjusted pass protection win rate (88.47), a list on which Marpet (87.14) was fifth.

Center

First Team: Ryan Jensen, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Second Team: Creed Humphrey, Kansas City Chiefs

Jensen led all centers with an adjusted run block win rate of 85.33%, while Humphrey’s hugely impressive rookie season so him finish second in that category on 84.40%.

Right Guard

First Team: Zack Martin, Dallas Cowboys

Second Team: Kevin Zeitler, Baltimore Ravens

No guard had a better adjusted pass block win rate than Martin’s 89.17% but Zeitler, who remains the picture of dependability, ran him close on 88.65. There was not much to separate them as run blockers, either, with Martin’s win rate of 83.69% putting him second behind Bitonio for guards with Zeitler (82.49) third.

Right Tackle

First Team: Tristan Wirfs, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Second Team: Lane Johnson, Philadelphia Eagles

It is no surprise the Buccaneers’ pass protection fell off a cliff in the divisional round without the injured Wirfs, who ended the regular season tied for first with Tyron Smith among tackles with an adjusted win rate of 93.69. However, Wirfs was involved in 315 one on one matchups compared to 189 for Cowboys left tackle Smith. Johnson trailed that duo on 89.61 but his pressure rate allowed of 3.8% was second only to Wirfs among right tackles with at least 200 pass protection snaps.

Swiss Army Knife

Deebo Samuel, San Francisco 49ers

It’s impossible to leave Samuel off a list of the best players in the NFL, but it is also tough to list him as a traditional wide receiver given how the 49ers used him during their surge to the NFC championship game. Third in the NFL with 1,770 scrimmage yards in the regular season, the self-described ‘wide back’ was a monster after contact. Kareem Hunt (2.84) was the sole running back (min. 50 carries) to average more yards after contact per attempt per rush than Deebo (2.67) when he lined up in position for a downhill carry. Among receivers with at least 100 targets, CeeDee Lamb and Chase were the two players to post a better rate of missed tackles per touch than Samuel.

2021 NFL leaders in yards after contact

DEFENSE

Defensive Tackle

First Team: Aaron Donald, Los Angeles Rams; Arik Armstead, San Francisco 49ers; Chris Jones, Kansas City Chiefs

Second Team: Jonathan Allen, Washington Football Team; Cameron Heyward, Pittsburgh Steelers; Derrick Brown, Carolina Panthers

A case does not need to be made for Donald, but here’s this piece of supporting evidence: His stunt-adjusted pass rush win rate of 63.83% was not only the highest for all defenders with at least 100 one on one matchups, it was over 10 percentage points higher than his nearest challenger, Myles Garrett (53.56). He was the only interior defensive lineman with a higher adjusted sack rate (5.5%) than Armstead (5.0). Save for Donald, Jones was the only other defensive tackle with a pressure rate of 22% or above to post a run disruption rate of 25% or higher.

Outside Linebacker

First Team: T.J. Watt, Pittsburgh Steelers; Von Miller, Los Angeles Rams

Second Team: Melvin Ingram, Kansas City Chiefs; Matt Judon, New England Patriots

Watt had the best adjusted win rate (45.27%) among stand-up outside pass rushers in another dominant season for the perennial NFL Defensive Player of the Year contender while Miller (43.40) was second in that regard as he has revitalized his career in Los Angeles. Ingram paired his win rate of 35.10% with a run disruption rate of 24.2% fifth among players with 100 edge snaps as he proved a trade steal for the Chiefs.

Edge

First Team: Myles Garrett, Cleveland Browns; Maxx Crosby, Las Vegas Raiders

Second Team: Nick Bosa, San Francisco 49ers; John Franklin-Myers, New York Jets

The aforementioned Garrett’s status as the top 4-3 edge rusher in the NFL was strengthened by another outstanding year for the underwhelming Browns, though he has plenty of competition. Crosby’s 244 one-on-ones were the second most in the NFL and he won 113 of them, putting him third behind Bosa (47.92) in adjusted win rate after the 49ers star won 85 of his 175. Franklin-Myers (41.80) was not the the only bright spot on the Jets’ defense.

Middle Linebacker

First Team: Bobby Wagner, Seattle Seahawks; Demario Davis, New Orleans Saints

Second Team: De’Vondre Campbell, Green Bay Packers; Fred Warner, San Francisco 49ers

Wagner allowed a big-play on 9.7% of his 60 targets in 2021, fourth-best among middle linebackers targeted at least 25 times. Top of that list was Davis (4.4%), who also was the premier player at the position in terms of combined open percentage allowed across man and zone coverage (11.95) with the consistently superb (14.60) not far behind despite an apparent down year during the regular season.

Cornerback

First Team: Bryce Hall, New York Jets; Casey Hayward, Las Vegas Raiders; Jalen Ramsey, Los Angeles Rams

Second Team: Darius Slay, Philadelphia Eagles; Jaylon Johnson, Chicago Bears; Taron Johnson, Buffalo Bills

Deployed frequently at the star position in the Rams’ defense, Ramsey’s burn yards per target allowed average of 5.98 was the best for players with at least 25 targets while playing inside corner. Hall played more man matchups than anyone with 235 and yet had the best combined open percentage allowed (14.61) of any corner to reach three figures. Hayward (14.83) was second with Slay (17.17) narrowly trailing the excellent Ramsey (17.07).

Strong Safety

First Team: Kevin Byard, Tennessee Titans

Second Team: Tyrann Mathieu, Arizona Cardinals

Across 107 matchups in man and zone, Byard’s combined open percentage allowed of 14.32 was first among safeties with at least 100. Mathieu did his best work in the slot, allowing 0.79 burn yards per snap, the third-best rate among defenders with a minimum of 50 coverage snaps at inside corner.

Free Safety

First Team: Xavier McKinney, New York Giants

Second Team: Justin Simmons, Denver Broncos

It was a breakout year for McKinney, who along with Simmons was one of six safeties to snag five interceptions in 2021. No safety had more than five picks and it was McKinney who was superior when it came to coverage, allowing a combined open percentage of 17.07 that trailed only Byard and Eric Rowe, though Simmons (18.65) was again among the elite.

Swiss Army Knife

Micah Parsons, Dallas Cowboys

Linebacker or designated pass rusher? Regardless of what you think Parsons’ role is, what is not up for debate is that he is worthy of a place on any All-Pro team. The likely Defensive Rookie of the Year’s pressure rate of 32.2% on 211 pass rush snaps was even superior to that of Donald while has run disruption rate of 13.7% was fourth among all linebackers.


Enjoy this? Subscribe to our mailing list to receive exclusive weekly content.

Kyle Cunningham-Rhoads and Greg Gifford contributed.